The Cult Next Door
The word “cult” carries heavy connotations; robes, kool-aid, isolation, compounds, and fanatic leaders. While that definitely exists, most cultic systems aren’t that obvious. They’re in the boardrooms. Business meetings. The pews. The group chats. The “spirit-led” staff meetings. The gym down the road. They operate through structure, shame, charisma, and control.
And sometimes, they look like churches.
Not all high-control religious systems are cults, but all cults operate with high control.
And if we want to understand how religious trauma takes root we need to examine the psychological mechanics of these environments and how they shape thought, behaviour, belonging, and fear.
Robert Jay Lifton’s 8 Criteria for Thought Reform
In his landmark work Thought Reform and the Psychology of Totalism (1961), psychiatrist Robert Jay Lifton outlined eight conditions that define coercive environments. While his research initially focused on political indoctrination in Chinese prison camps his framework has since been applied to cults, extremist movements, and, importantly, high-control religious settings.
Let’s explore each one, with a trauma-informed lens on how these dynamics show up in modern spiritual environments.
1. Milieu Control
Control of the environment and communication, both within and outside the group.
In high-control churches, this looks like:
“Accountability partners” reporting on your behaviour.
Discouragement from consuming outside information or questioning leadership.
Closed staff WhatsApp groups used to monitor emotional tone and compliance.
Warning people not to engage with “former members” or “the spiritually deceived.”
Milieu control is how systems gatekeep truth and isolate dissent.
2. Mystical Manipulation
Leaders position events as divinely orchestrated to reinforce their authority.
This often sounds like:
“God told me you were meant to lead this ministry.”
“It’s no coincidence you’re going through this, it’s a test of faith.”
“If you leave now, God will remove the anointing from your life.”
When manipulation is cloaked in spirituality it becomes harder to question without fearing spiritual consequences.
3. Demand for Purity
A rigid dichotomy of good vs. evil, saved vs. lost, pure vs. defiled.
In these systems:
Struggles are moralised (“You’re lukewarm” instead of “You’re burnt out”).
Sexuality is shamed, especially for women and the LGBTQIA+ community.
Doubts are labelled as spiritual attacks.
Perfection is the goal and authenticity is a threat.
4. Confession
Personal struggles are expected to be disclosed, often publicly or to authority figures.
At its worst:
Confession becomes surveillance.
Vulnerability becomes ammunition.
Disclosures made in trust are used to control or punish.
I remember a leader “praying” about something I shared privately, on stage and without my permission. And I was expected to thank them for their discernment.
5. Sacred Science
The group’s beliefs are presented as ultimate truth that is unchallengeable and non-negotiable.
Think:
“The Bible says…” as the end of a conversation.
Leaders claiming “divine downloads” you can’t question.
Doubt being reframed as disobedience and spiritual immaturity.
The belief system becomes above scrutiny and so do its leaders.
6. Loading the Language
Using jargon and insider language to control thought.
Examples include:
“Covering,” “out of alignment,” “servant heart,” “rebellious spirit.”
Reducing complex trauma to “offense” or “pride.”
Equating emotional distress with “a lack of faith.”
Language becomes a tool of containment. If you can’t name what’s happening to you, how can you challenge it?
7. Doctrine over Person
Personal experiences are secondary to the group’s teachings.
If you’re abused it’s “your test.”
If you’re mentally ill, it’s “a lack of prayer.”
If you’re excluded, it’s “for your refinement.”
This principle silences survivors.
It says: “What happened to you doesn’t matter, what matters is how loyal you stayed.”
8. Dispensing of Existence
Those who leave, question, or disobey are spiritually invalidated or erased entirely.
You’ll hear:
“They were never truly saved.”
“They’re bitter. Don’t listen to them.”
“God removed them.”
For me, the moment I stepped back, my phone stopped ringing. 98% of the people I prayed with, led with, wept with just vanished.
It wasn’t personal. It was policy.
The Subtle Shape of Coercion
Lifton’s criteria help us name something that survivors often struggle to articulate: the slow erosion of autonomy. It doesn’t always feel like trauma in the moment, sometimes, it feels like loyalty, devotion, and purpose.
But coercion wrapped in spiritual language is still coercion.
Here’s what I’ve heard from clients (and felt myself):
“I was afraid to lose my whole community.”
“I was told that I would burn in hell for all eternity.”
“I thought I was being disobedient to God.”
“I was taught that questioning was rebellion.”
“I didn’t want to be the one who let the team down.”
High-control systems don’t just control your beliefs. They become your identity, your relationships, your calendar, your finances, your worth, and your eternal security.
Leaving is not just walking out a door. It’s rebuilding an entire life.
One of the hardest parts of recovering from spiritual abuse is reconciling the “good times” with the harm.
You may think:
“They loved me.”
“I chose to be there.”
“Not everything was bad.”
And all of that may be true.
Coercive systems aren’t 100% harm. They’re a mix of belonging, belief, and betrayal. That’s what makes them so powerful and so confusing to untangle from.
But here’s a truth that has helped me and many of my clients:
Something can feel good and still be harmful.
You can have made meaningful connections and still name the system as abusive.
You can have loved people and still choose to walk away.
A Note on Language: Not All High-Control Environments Are Cults
Using the term “cult” requires care. It’s important not to weaponise the word to describe organisation or person you disagree with. But it’s equally important not to avoid it when it fits.
Instead of obsessing over labels, we can ask:
Did this group demand absolute loyalty?
How did I feel about my own worth?
Was questioning punished?
Were decisions made through fear, shame, or spiritual manipulation?
Did I feel free to leave?
What were the consequences when I did decide to leave?
Was I able to make my own decisions or did they need to align with the group or the beliefs?
If the answer is no, you may have been in a high-control or cultic system.
Naming that is not an attack. It’s a step toward truth.
What Recovery Can Look Like
Leaving is one part of the journey. Unlearning is another.
Here are some things that have helped me and my clients:
1. Psychoeducation
Learning about trauma responses, thought reform, and coercion can reduce self-blame and offer context.
2. Somatic Safety – When it feels safe
The nervous system needs to learn that it’s safe to pause, feel, and rest. Practices like grounding, orienting, safe touch, and Havening Techniques can support this process.
3. Grief and Anger Work
There’s grief in realising what you were part of and anger is part of recovery. You’re not bitter, you’re brave enough to name what happened.
4. Community That Doesn’t Demand Conformity
Finding people who don’t require you to perform, hide, or shrink. This can be life-changing.
5. Therapeutic Support
Working with someone who understands religious trauma and cult recovery is crucial. Not every practitioner is trauma-informed around high-control spiritual abuse. That’s why I do this work.
Power Wasn’t the Problem - Abuse of It Was
Religion isn’t inherently abusive and faith isn’t inherently coercive. But when power is hoarded, dissent is punished, and fear is spiritualised, that’s not faith.
That’s control.
If you’ve ever felt like you were slowly disappearing in the name of obedience, this is your invitation to reappear.
Work with me: If you're navigating religious trauma or cult recovery, I offer individual coaching, group support, and coaching packages. Learn more about how we can work together.
Connect on Instagram: Follow along for insights, resources, and community.
Check Out The Religious Trauma Collective: Looking for more support and connection? The Religious Trauma Collective offers resources, community, and advocacy for anyone impacted by religious harm.