“I Don’t Know How to Describe It”: Why Survivors Struggle to Tell Their Own Story

Most people, when they try to explain what happened to them inside a high-control group, run into a wall somewhere in the middle of the telling. They know the events. They can report what happened, more or less, in the sequence it happened. But at some point, usually the point where the story most needs to be told, the words stop working. The explanation that made complete sense inside the system sounds inadequate, or even self-incriminating, from outside it. The explanation that makes sense from outside it doesn’t capture what the experience was actually like from inside.

They end up saying something like:

“I don’t know how to describe it.”

“It’s hard to explain.”

“You’d have to have been there.”

And then they watch the person they’re trying to explain it to nod politely and file it somewhere in the general category of “religious experience that got a bit intense,” which is about as far from the truth as it’s possible to get while technically not disagreeing.

This isn’t a failure of articulacy. It’s the predictable outcome of several converging forces, each of which deserves to be understood on its own terms. Survivors are not unreliable narrators of their own lives. They’re narrators who’ve been handed a broken set of tools for the specific task of telling this particular story.

What the Group Did to the Story Before You Left

One of the most sophisticated things high-control groups do, and they do it well before anyone leaves, is pre-emptively construct the narrative of what it means to leave. This is so important to understand that it’s worth sitting with it for a moment before moving on.

By the time you exit a high-control group, the group has already written the story of your exit. They’ve written it in the sermons you’ve heard about people who fell away. In the cautionary tales told about former members. In the theological framework that explains what kind of person leaves and why. The story was written before you left, and it was written specifically to foreclose any alternative account you might offer.

The available stories are almost always variations on a small number of themes: you left because of pride, because of sin, because you were deceived by the world, because you couldn’t handle the demands of real commitment, because someone hurt your feelings and you couldn’t forgive, because you wanted to live without accountability, because the enemy got hold of you. The specifics vary by group and tradition, but the underlying structure is consistent: you left because something was wrong with you, and the fact that you’re now speaking critically about the group is itself evidence of that wrongness.

This pre-written narrative does something insidious to survivors’ capacity to tell their own story. It means that before you’ve even opened your mouth, you’re already arguing against an account of you and your exit that exists in the minds of anyone still connected to the group. Your account has already been categorised as self-serving, spiritually compromised, and unreliable. The group’s account of why you left has been distributed to the community that knows you, often without your knowledge, while you were still finding your footing.

And because you internalised the group’s frameworks over years of immersion, some part of you is also arguing against that account inside your own head. You’re not just trying to tell your story. You’re trying to tell it while simultaneously defending it against a counter-narrative that’s running in the background of your own mind, one that was installed by the very system you’re trying to describe.

Trauma’s Effect on Narrative Coherence

There’s a neurobiological dimension to this that sits underneath the ideological one, and it matters for understanding why the story is so hard to tell.

Trauma affects memory and narrative in specific and well-documented ways. Traumatic experiences, particularly those involving chronic threat rather than single events, are not stored and retrieved the way ordinary autobiographical memories are. They tend to be fragmented, non-linear, and encoded primarily in sensory and somatic form rather than in the coherent narrative form that ordinary storytelling requires. The experience is present, but it’s present as sensation, as body memory, as emotional weather, rather than as a sequence of events with a clear beginning, middle, and end.

This means that when a survivor tries to tell their story, they’re often trying to construct a linear narrative from material that isn’t stored linearly.

  • They know something happened.

  • They know how it felt.

  • They may have very precise memories of specific moments, particular conversations, specific things that were said.

But the connective tissue of the narrative, the causal logic that links events into a coherent account of what happened and why, can be genuinely difficult to access.

Add to this the specific effect of the loaded language problem I described in a previous post. If the language available to you for describing your inner experience was shaped by the group’s framework, your memories of that inner experience are encoded in the group’s language. Retrieving them means either using that language, which carries the group’s interpretive framework into the telling, or translating them into new language, which requires a degree of processing and integration that may not yet have happened.

The result is that survivors often feel like they’re telling a story they haven’t yet fully understood themselves. They’re reporting from the inside of an experience that they’re still making sense of, in language that either belongs to the system they’re describing or feels inadequate to the reality of what they lived through. The frustration of “I don’t know how to describe it” is the frustration of trying to narrate an experience whose own language is part of what needs to be critically examined.

Loaded Language and the Disappearing Story

Loaded language doesn’t just shape how you thought inside the group. It shapes how you remember, because memory and language are not separate systems. The words available to you at the time of an experience shape how that experience is encoded, and those encoded memories are retrieved in the form they were stored.

If the language available to you for understanding your own suffering was “spiritual warfare,” “a season of testing,” “God refining you,” or “the cost of discipleship,” then your memories of that suffering are partially stored in those frames. Retrieving them means either accepting the frame (which misrepresents the experience as something other than harm) or rejecting the frame (which can leave you feeling like you’re reaching for something that isn’t quite there yet).

This is one reason why survivors so often describe their pre-exit experience as confusing to narrate. Inside the system, everything had an explanation. The explanations were often wrong, or were serving the system’s interests rather than their own, but they were explanations. They gave the experience a story. After exit, when those explanations no longer hold, the experiences they were explaining can feel temporarily without story. Something happened, but the narrative container that once held it has been dismantled, and the new container isn’t built yet.

This period of narrative limbo is disorienting and often profoundly isolating. People want you to be able to tell them what happened. They want a clear account, with a beginning and an end, that they can process and respond to. The honest answer, that you’re still figuring out what happened and what it meant, doesn’t give them anything to hold onto, and it can leave you feeling even more alone with the not-yet-formed story than you were before you tried to tell it.

Being Pressed to Justify What You Experienced

One more layer compounds all of this, and it’s the one survivors often find most exhausting: the social pressure to produce a credible account of your experience for people who didn’t share it.

When you try to explain what happened inside a high-control group to someone who’s never been inside one, you frequently encounter a set of questions that are individually reasonable but that cumulatively have the effect of putting you on trial for your own experience.

  • Why did you stay so long?

  • Why didn’t you just leave?

  • What specifically was abusive?

  • Can you give me an example?

But wasn’t there also good stuff? Isn’t it possible you’re misremembering? Don’t you think you might be being a bit extreme?

Each of these questions requires you to do the work of defending the reality of your experience to someone who doesn’t have the framework to evaluate it, while simultaneously managing your own emotional response to being cross-examined about something that caused you real harm. And because the group has already distributed its account of your exit, some of the people asking these questions are already in possession of a counter-narrative that positions your account as suspect.

The pressure to produce a justifiable, coherent, externally credible account of your experience can actually interfere with the recovery of narrative authority, because it forces you to tell the story in a form that’s shaped by what others need to hear rather than what actually happened. You end up performing a version of your story that’s calibrated for external credibility, which is a very different thing from actually integrating and owning your own account of your life.

What Reclaiming Narrative Authority Actually Looks Like

Narrative authority, the capacity to be the primary author of your own story rather than a character in someone else’s account of it, doesn’t return all at once. It returns through a gradual process of telling and revising and sitting with the uncertainty of stories that are still being understood.

It requires access to language that can actually describe the experience, which is why frameworks like coercive control, thought reform, loaded language, and bounded choice are so useful for survivors. Not because they’re the only true account of what happened, but because they give access to a vocabulary that can describe the dynamics of control without relying on the group’s own interpretive framework. Many survivors describe a specific kind of relief when they first encounter these frameworks: not the relief of having everything explained, but the relief of having language that fits the shape of what they remember.

It requires permission to tell a story that’s still incomplete. Your account of what happened doesn’t have to be finished to be true. You’re allowed to say “I’m still figuring out what that period of my life was” and have that be a complete and honest account rather than a failed attempt at one. The pressure to produce a finished narrative before you’ve had the space to actually process the experience is a pressure you’re allowed to put down.

It requires people who can receive an incomplete, non-linear, sometimes contradictory account without rushing to resolve it into something more digestible. A good therapist, a peer survivor community, a trusted person who’s willing to sit with you in the not-yet-formed story: these matter enormously. Narrative coherence develops in relational context. You can’t build your own account in isolation, and you can’t build it under cross-examination. You need witnesses who are genuinely on your side.

And it requires, over time, the willingness to reclaim authorship over the parts of your story that were written by the group in your absence. To look at the account they distributed of why you left, what kind of person you were inside the group, what your exit meant, and to say: that’s their story about me, not mine. Mine is still being written. And I’m the one writing it.

The Story Is Yours

If you’ve ever tried to explain what happened to you and found yourself trailing off into “it’s hard to describe,” that difficulty is not evidence that nothing significant happened, it’s evidence that what happened was complex enough, and the forces working against your capacity to narrate it were sophisticated enough, that telling the story is genuinely hard work.

You’re not an unreliable narrator. You’re a narrator who’s been given a broken map, told the territory doesn’t exist, and asked to describe it to people who’ve never been there.

The map can be replaced.

The territory is real.

And the story, when you get to tell it in language that fits it, in a context that can receive it, on a timeline that belongs to you, is yours.

Next
Next

Reclaiming “I Think,” “I Feel,” “I Want”